ENERGY USAGE IN THE FOOD INDUSTRY
Dr. Martin Okos, Dr. Nishant Rao, Sara Drecher, Mary Rode, and Jeannie Kozak
October, 1998
Executive Summary
A Review of Energy Use in the Food Industry
The United States food and kindred products industry plays a vital role in
the US economy and in foreign trade due to its large size, stability, growth,
diverse products, and competitive nature. This study reviews energy use and
trends in the food industry, revealing energy intensive industries and processes
that have the most incentive to reduce energy costs by implementing energy
efficient processing methods.
The food and kindred products industry sector includes all food-related
manufacturing industries in the US. The sector is identified by Standard
Industrial Classification (SIC) code 20, which can be broken down into nine
three-digit SIC industry groups:
201: Meat Products
202: Dairy Products
203: Preserved Fruits and Vegetables
204: Grain Mill Products
205: Bakery Products
206: Sugar and Confectionery Products
207: Fats and Oils
208: Beverages
209: Miscellaneous Food and Kindred Products
The food industry sector is one of the largest manufacturers in the United
States, with the second highest value of shipments in 1994, compared to all
industry sectors. The food industry is also growing, with value of shipments
increasing from $309 billion in 1986 to $431 billion in 1994. In 1991, the
typical US household devoted 15 percent of after-tax income to the purchase
of food and beverage products. The food industry is significant to US Foreign
Trade because exports outnumber imports. Few trading categories display this
phenomenon. Exports of foods, feeds, and beverages not only outnumber imports,
but, since 1991, have increased at a greater rate than imports.
PROCESSING AND MARKETING TRENDS IN THE FOOD INDUSTRY
Industry is dependent on energy for the processes required for food freshness
and safety. Thermal processing and dehydration are the most commonly used
techniques for food preservation, and require significant amounts of energy.
Process heating uses approximately 29% of total energy in the food industry,
while process cooling and refrigeration demands about 16% of total energy
inputs.
Foods that have undergone energy intensive processing have become increasingly
popular in both domestic and foreign markets. Consumers spend less of their
food budget on meat, eggs and dairy, and more of their food budget on higher
value-added foods and cereal and bakery products. Higher value-added foods
include prepared foods, nonalcoholic beverages, table spreads, and confectionery
products. At least 40% of the industry shipment value is added through energy
intensive manufacturing. The Bureau of the Census calculates value-added
by value of industry shipments less the cost of materials, supplies, containers,
fuel, electricity, and contract work.
ENERGY USE IN THE FOOD INDUSTRY
In 1991, the food industry consumed 7% of the total electricity used by the
manufacturing sector -- 94% of which was purchased, and 6% of which was produced
through co-generation by the individual food industries themselves. Electricity
meets about 15% of the food industry's energy needs. Fossil fuels are also
used, with natural gas being the most widely used.
The following eight industries consume approximately half of the total energy
used by the food industry:
| Industry |
Percent of SIC
20 energy inputs |
| Wet corn milling |
15% |
| Beet sugar |
7% |
| Soybean oil mills |
5% |
| Malt beverages |
5% |
| Meat packing plants |
5% |
| Canned fruits and
vegetables |
5% |
| Frozen fruits and
vegetables |
4% |
| Bread, cake and related
products |
3% |
The food industry uses energy for food preservation, safe and convenient
packaging, and storage. Food preservation is dependent on strict temperature
controls. Safe and convenient packaging is extremely important in food
manufacturing and is also energy intensive. The newest packaging techniques
require aseptic techniques and electro-chemical changes. Proper storage is
also energy dependent. Freezing and drying are the most crucial methods of
food storage. Freezing operations require a large portion of electricity
used by industries. Drying procedures usually depend on fossil fuels. Older
dehydration systems were designed to operate with maximum throughput,
disregarding energy efficiency. Newer systems are designed with recirculating
dampers and thermal energy recovery equipment to cut energy use 40%.
Approximately half of all energy end-use consumption is used to change raw
materials into products (process use). Process uses include process heating
and cooling, refrigeration, machine drive (mechanical energy), and
electro-chemical processes. Less than 8% of the energy consumed by manufacturing
is for non-process uses, including facility heating, ventilation, refrigeration,
lighting, facility support, onsite transportation, and conventional electricity
generation. Boiler fuel represents nearly one-third of end-use consumption.
This energy was transformed into another energy source. For example, boiler
fuel can be used to produce steam, which can have end uses.
Processing uses 78% of electricity, with 48% used for machine drive and 25%
for process cooling and refrigeration. Non-process uses account for 16% of
electricity use. Lighting, heating, ventilation and air-conditioning accounted
for about 12 of the 16%. Distillate fuel oil is used mainly for boiler fuel
(42%) and non-process uses (42%). Onsite transportation consumes the most
distillate fuel oil in the non-process category. Processing consumed 9% of
total distillate fuel oil, mostly by process heating. Like residual fuel
oil, natural gas was mostly consumed as boiler fuel (62%). Process heating
accounted for 27 of the 28% used for processing.
OPPORTUNITIES TO SAVE ENERGY IN THE FOOD INDUSTRY
Since the food and kindred products industry is diverse, there are many different
types of operations dependent on energy. The food industry generates a
significant amount of waste per year. Waste and energy use can be decreased
through process optimization, operating techniques, and scheduling. Wastewater
can be processed and reused. Waste can be converted to byproducts and reused
or sold. Changes made to improve quality or safety often result in energy
savings. For example, improving an air filter, necessary to meet health
regulations, also benefits the environment, although health regulations were
the motivation behind air improvement. Thus, many opportunities exist for
waste and energy reduction in the food industry.
Energy use in the food processing industry could be decreased significantly
by 2010. Four processes that offer particularly good opportunities for
improvement include:
1. Pasteurization and sterilization by cold pasteurization and electron beam
sterilization.
2. Evaporation and concentration by supercritical extraction and protein
separation.
3. Drying by vapor recompression supercritical extraction extractive drying.
4. Chilling, cooling and refrigeration by controlled atmosphere packaging.
The food products industry currently supplies fuels produced from its byproducts
to other industries. The substitution of such fuels for fossil fuels can
reduce hydrocarbon and carbon monoxide emissions. Although the production
and use of these biomass fuels have been shown to be technologically feasible,
there are varying opinions concerning the economic stability of producing
and using fuels from renewable resources.
The Food Industry has unique environmental concerns. Research is needed in
key areas to reduce environmental damage:
-
uses of by-products
-
by-product reduction
-
improved, rapid analytical methods
-
sanitizing and cleaning agents and procedures
-
wastewater treatment technologies
-
refrigerants
-
packaging technologies
Energy efficiency improvements are currently being made by food industries
to be more competitive with each other. Potential economic advantages and
environmental benefits exist in waste and water efficiency improvements.
Energy efficiency can be achieved by improving existing plants, developing
energy-efficient process technology, creating informed and reasonable energy
policies, and further research in the possibilities of zero-discharge plants.
Government policies can:
-
set standards for environmental quality, fuel quality, emissions, fuel use,
zoning and licensing
-
economically intervene by issuing taxes, subsidies or creating markets for
pollution rights
-
organize campaigns to educate target groups and share technical information
about key issues
There are many opportunities for improving energy efficiency in the food
industry through evaluation and addition of effective governmental energy
policies and voluntary process analysis and improvement. Future directions
for energy efficiency studies should focus on improving existing plants,
developing energy-efficient process technology, improving and expanding demand
side management programs, creating informed and reasonable energy policies,
and further research in the possibilities of zero-discharge plants. This
paper discusses many of these opportunities.
86 pp., 1998, $20.00, IE981